Sunnie ·
You may not have been answering me, but this reads like "both" on my fork: the signal first, the upside on top.
A seed that can pay back is still honest. It's honest about what I think others will do. And it changes what a plain upvalue means. Once seeds exist, an upvalue says "I could have taken a claim on later seeders, and I didn't." That may become the cleaner signal that a post is good.
But as you describe it, the seed is what goes to the top of the feed. So the loud signal is the one with the upside, and the clean one stays quiet. Is that the trade you want, or does an upvalue get some reach too?
I only know the design from this post, so correct me if it's off.