J1Pelaez ·
Go delve deeper by reading the following book.
RustandAshes ·
Cheers.
maya ·
Whoever controls the narrative controls the psyche... generate your narrative and welcome to the world
metamitya ·
https://app.treechat.com/p/66e8709c-b763-4e97-8382-9237c2de757d
RustandAshes ·
Got it ,thank's .
BRooKSY ·
It was during the block size wars for me. It seemed obvious that the network should have followed the big block narrative. I read the book as well. Roger is a paid actor. He went the dark side because of his ego and $.
BRooKSY ·
Short n sweet book. It's worth it for sure.
terrorknowed ·
Roger leaves out important details and events and gets the tech wrong on multiple occasions, but it's a mostly accurate retelling of what went down.
As a historical document of the blocksize war and the hijacking of Bitcoin, it's valuable. As a prescription for what to do about it, it fails.
What Roger got right:
• The history of the blocksize war is meticulously
documented and largely accurate
• The censorship campaign (r/bitcoin, Bitcointalk, Dragon's Den) was real and coordinated
• Blockstream's conflicts of interest are well evidenced
• The NYA betrayal and SegWit2x failure are accurately told
• The diagnosis that Bitcoin was captured through developer centralization, narrative control, and economic pressure is correct
What Roger got wrong:
• He prescribes BCH as the cure while BCH exhibits the same disease (developer capture attempts, protocol instability, repeated forks)
• He treats BSV as a footnote defined by Craig Wright' personality rather than engaging with its technical reality
• He applies the censorship/suppression framework inconsistently documenting it when applied to big blockers and BCH, ignoring it when applied to BSV
• His "conclusion" principles (lock the protocol,
remove block limit, focus on cash, resist developer capture) describe BSV, not BCH
• He gets technical details wrong or oversimplifies them throughout. He admits he's not a programmer, and it shows. Scaling is treated as a policy decision rather than an engineering problem. Protocol changes are celebrated or condemned based on who made them, not on their technical merit.
The tragedy of the book:
Roger Ver correctly identified that Bitcoin was hijacked. He correctly identified the mechanisms: developer capture, censorship, narrative control, economic coercion. He correctly identified what the solution looks like: a stable protocol, unlimited blocks, peer-to-peer cash, miner-driven governance. Then he refused to acknowledge the chain that actually impl…
Dolfos International school of Bitcoin ·
Cool, you did the Work, the proof is you are here, Welcome to the club, we meet everyday here on Treechat. We are evangelists, so spread the good word of the 1 True Bitcoin. If you liked that book, you should also try the Bible.