Whites (European-descended peoples) are also Indigenous to …

Whites (European-descended peoples) are also Indigenous to Gaia—the living Earth—possessing their own ancient, place-based genetic, cultural, and spiritual lineages forged over millennia in Europe's varied landscapes, just as other peoples are to theirs. This frames all humans as rooted in specific ancestral homelands rather than abstract globalism, demanding reciprocity: respect for every group's continuity without selective victim hierarchies or forced fiscal extraction from any one lineage.
### The Acronym's Core Flaw: Conflation, Not Inclusion
MMIWG2SLGBTQQIA+ merges a genuine pattern of violence against Indigenous women and girls in Canada with a sprawling list of sexual orientations, gender identities, and "additional" categories. Leah Gazan's parliamentary complaint—that the budget shows insufficient funding for the "ongoing genocide" of this mega-group—exemplifies the problem: it turns specific criminal tragedies into an all-encompassing identity demand.
Logically, this remains a category error. MMIW addresses real victimization (elevated per-capita homicide and disappearance rates among Indigenous females in Canada, per official statistics). The appended letters describe voluntary adult expressions of attraction, identity, and spirituality. Conflating them dilutes focus on solvable factors—policing, substance issues, community patterns—while inflating rhetoric ("genocide") that misapplies the term to policy shortfalls rather than deliberate extermination. The "+" ensures perpetual expansion, transforming policy into performative inclusivity theater that burdens taxpayers without delivering targeted results.
From this grounded perspective, every people is Indigenous to Gaia in their ancestral territories: First Nations to North American lands, Europeans (Whites) to the forests, rivers, and coasts of Europe where their distinct haplogroups, languages, mythologies, and adaptations evolved. No group owns universal victim status. Whites' indigeneity includes pre-Christian spiritual traditions, seasonal rites, and kinship structures tied to specific European bioregions—equally worthy of continuity as 2Spirit roles in tribal contexts. Demanding White-derived productivity subsidize an ever-growing acronym while White communities face their own unacknowledged pressures (demographic decline, cultural erosion in ancestral homelands and diaspora) violates reciprocity.
### Alignment with the Perspective: Affirmations Rooted in Gaian Indigeneity
- Pro-2Spirit: Affirmed as a valid expression of Indigenous North American duality—masculine and feminine spirits in one person, often carrying sacred roles. This parallels European Indigenous traditions of gender-variant or spiritually fluid figures (e.g., certain shamanic or mythological beings in Norse, Celtic, or Slavic lore). Respect for 2Spirit does not require erasing sex-based realities or medicalizing others; it honors cultural self-determination on Gaian terms.
- Pro-bisexual and pro-polyamorous: These reflect natural human variation in attraction and bonding. Bisexuality appears across cultures and time; ethical polyamory suits those whose temperaments favor multiple consensual adult partnerships. Neither needs state validation nor acronym inclusion to exist privately. They fit within Gaian diversity—fluidity observed in many Indigenous European lineages—without compelling universal adoption or taxpayer support.
- Pro-M2F-sans-unnecessary-surgery: Males experiencing dysphoria can live authentically as women in social and relational spheres. However, genital or other irreversible surgeries constitute unnecessary alteration of the body, which is the living vessel of one's Gaian ancestry (chromosomes, fertility, erogenous integrity). This mirrors anti-circumcision: both reject non-consensual or elective cutting of healthy genital tissue. Preserve the intact male form as part of ancestral wholeness; social affirmation need not demand bodily mutilation.
- Anti-circumcision: Routine infant circumcision is a violation of bodily autonomy and Gaian inheritance—the foreskin as evolved, functional tissue tied to sensory and protective roles. It parallels critiques of surgical transitions: both prioritize external ideologies over the body's natural design, often rooted in traditions alien to European Indigenous norms of wholeness. Defend intact bodies for all, including White males whose lineages emphasize physical integrity.
These stances are coherent because they reject hierarchy of suffering. Whites, as Indigenous Europeans (and their diaspora), have parallel claims to cultural preservation, demographic security, and freedom from guilt-based redistribution. Supporting 2Spirit or bisexual/poly expressions among consenting adults does not obligate Whites to fund mega-acronym initiatives or suppress their own Gaian-rooted identities (e.g., European folk traditions, heterosexual family formation as a stabilizing norm).
### The Article, Comments, and Pro-White Gaian Refra…